Description
Presentation at the "Justice beyond Criminal Justice" symposium, organised by the Department of Social & Policy Sciences, University of Bath.Abstract
“But do you condemn Hamas?” has become a familiar challenge directed at individuals expressing horror against the atrocities in Gaza or sympathy for the Palestinian people. The dubious popularity of this refrain in public discourse has been duly recognised by its own Wikipedia entry.
Statements of condemnation in times of war are frequently used to express moral outrage against the aggressor, and solidarity with the victim. These binary positions are outwardly unproblematic where allegiances cohere with the known divide between “liberal” and “illiberal” states (Foa et al., 2022). Israel’s actions in Gaza, since recognised by some scholars and experts as genocidal crimes, have exposed the contradictions of the West’s supposed liberalism, and the limits to statements of condemnation as a form of discourse.
This project, which takes its inspiration from The Humument (Phillips, 2016), efface the text of the European Society of Criminology’s 2022 statement on the war in Ukraine. Utilising push-pull-slide mechanisms often found in children’s picture books, locations and times in the original text have been replaced and reordered to render meaning unstable. It invites the audience to attend to three observations: whose hand ultimately controls the mechanism; what has been constrained or muted by the “ritual” of condemnations (Foucault, 1970/2005); and whether equity, which Nussbaum (1993) called the “gentle art of particular perception”, can better serve the ends of justice.
| Period | 29 Oct 2025 |
|---|---|
| Held at | University of Bath, United Kingdom |
Keywords
- Social justice
- Phenomenology
- Equity
- Creative methodologies
- discourse analysis