Climatic resources mediate the shape and strength of grassland productivity-richness relationships from local to regional scales

The plant productivity and species richness (P-SR) relationship has been a central topic in ecology for decades. It is increasingly recognized that climate resources (CR, temperature and precipitation) might affect the P-SR relationship as (1) the response of plant productivity and species richness to CR are different; (2) plant-plant interactions change along the CR gradient. However, little is known about how these effects mediate the shape and strength of the P-SR relationship from local-site to regional scales. Here, we proposed a cross-scale framework to disentangle the climatic control over the P-SR relationship in grasslands using the HerbDivNet dataset, which covers 28 natural grasslands in 19 countries and 6 continents with wide precipitation and temperature gradients. Our results showed that, at the local-site scale, a humped-back P-SR relationship is common at sites under poor and rich CR conditions, whereas both the shape and strength of the P-SR relationship strongly vary among sites under moderate CR condition. However, at the regional scale, the humped-back P-SR relationship is only observed under poor CR condition. We suggested that the asynchronous responses of productivity and species richness to increasing CR is an abiotic driver of the inconsistent P-SR relationships along the climatic gradient in addition to the changing plant-plant interactions suggested by the stress-gradient hypothesis. These findings help to reconcile the long-standing debate over the P-SR relationship and highlight the importance of CR conditions in developing or comparing grassland ecosystem theories and management at small scales.