Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Does a reduction in knee loading constitute a reduction in pain when wearing lateral wedge insoles?

  • R.K. Jones
  • , G.J. Chapman
  • , M.J. Parkes
  • , L.M. Forsythe
  • , D.T. Felson

Research output: Contribution to journal › Meeting Abstract › peer-review

Abstract

Purpose: Previous research has shown that lateral wedge insoles reduce the external knee adduction moment (EKAM) during gait and stair ascent and descent. However, recent randomised trials have failed to find a reduction in knee pain with the use of lateral wedge insoles. Around 30% of individuals have an increase (biomechanical non-responder) in their EKAM with lateral wedge insoles, which suggests that if biomechanical responders and non-responders are looked at separately, a potential relationship between EKAM and pain reduction may be seen. Therefore, the hypotheses of this paper were to determine whether lateral wedge insoles produce an immediate pain reduction during walking and secondly; if a change in EKAM has any relationship with this immediate change in pain when wearing lateral wedge insoles.

Methods: We studied participants with painful medial knee OA who noted pain on walking. In a one day study, they all tried three treatments with the order of the treatments randomised, two different lateral wedge insoles and a control shoe. The major difference between the lateral wedge insoles (Boston and Salford) is one has a medial arch support (Salford). During trials, lateral wedge insoles were inserted into the control shoes and were worn bilaterally. During each treatment, participants underwent a 3D kinematic (Qualysis OQUS, Sweden) and kinetic (AMTI, USA) analysis. As they completed each treatment, participants were asked to compare the knee pain experienced while walking to pain when wearing their own shoes and were asked to score this pain on a 5-point Likert scale scored from much worse to much better than their own shoes. We classified participants as biomechanical responders; if participants had a decreased EKAM wearing both lateral wedge conditions (compared to the control shoe). Biomechanical non-responders were classified if their EKAM increased when wearing both lateral wedges compared to the control shoe. Difference in pain compared to the control shoe was assessed using a Wilcoxon sign rank test; change in EKAM was assessed using 95% CIs constructed around the mean EKAM change. Finally, Spearman's rank correlation was used to assess if the change in the pain rankings related to the change in EKAM.

Results: We studied 70 participants (43 male, 27 female). Overall (N=70), pain was reduced when using both types of lateral wedge insole (Wedge Average z = -3.63, p <0.001; Boston z = -2.24; p= 0.03; Salford z = -4.32; p <0.001) in comparison to the control shoe. EKAM also reduced when using a lateral wedge insole in comparison to the control shoe. Participants’ biomechanical response to wearing both types of lateral wedge insoles varied considerably with 20% (n=14) of participants demonstrating an increase in EKAM (median change in EKAM 0.028Nm/kg; IQR 0.011Nm/kg to 0.047Nm/kg) and 54% (n=38) demonstrating a decrease in EKAM (median change in EKAM -0.044Nm/kg; IQR -0.063Nm/kg to -0.025Nm/kg). The remainder had inconsistent EKAM responses to the wedges.We found no significant relationship between reduction in EKAM and reduction in pain in wedges (R = -0.14; 95% CI -0.36 to 0.10), or for either wedge separately (Boston R = -0.013; 95% -0.25 to 0.22); Salford R = -0.21; 95% CI -0.43 to 0.03). Similarly, pain reduction did not differ between responders and non-responders, again either for the wedges on average (N = 52, z = 0.39 for difference between responders and non-responders, p = 0.69), for the Boston (N = 52, z = -0.36, p = 0.72), or the Salford wedge (N = 52, z = -0.11, p = 0.92).

Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate that the degree of reduction in EKAM using lateral wedge insole does not correlate at all with immediate pain reduction with use of these insoles. Even those who have substantial reductions in EKAM when using the insole do not experience any more pain reduction than those without any EKAM reduction. This suggests that modestly reducing the EKAM may not reduce knee pain in persons with knee OA when assessed immediately after prescription.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)S89-S90
Number of pages2
JournalOsteoarthritis and Cartilage
Volume21
Issue numberSupplement
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2013
Event2013 OARSI World Congress - Philadelphia, United States
Duration: 18 Apr 2013 → 21 Apr 2013

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Does a reduction in knee loading constitute a reduction in pain when wearing lateral wedge insoles?'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this