Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Perceptions of Student Feedback: A comparative study of AI-generated and Human-generated content

  • University of York

Research output: Preprint/Working paper › Preprint

Abstract

Effective feedback is crucial for learning and academic improvement, yet students often find it lacking in detail and timeliness from teachers. The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) like ChatGPT offers promises to enhance feedback quality. This study compares student perceptions of AI-generated versus Human-generated feedback across two dimensions: Pleasing and Helpfulness, while also examining factors such as academic locus of control and attitudes towards AI. Results from 50 psychology students show that while AI-generated feedback was rated higher in Pleasing, Helpfulness ratings did not differ significantly. Even when comparing feedback with identical marks awarded by both ChatGPT and Human markers, AI feedback still received higher ratings. This suggests that, when the source is undisclosed, students prefer AI feedback, despite its comparable usefulness to Human feedback. This has implications for improving feedback efficiency in universities, potentially reducing time and costs. Limitations and future research directions are discussed.
Original languageEnglish
Publisherfigshare
Pages1-26
Number of pages26
DOIs
Publication statusIn preparation - 15 Jul 2026

Keywords

  • ChatGPT in HE
  • Educator perspectives of AI integration
  • AI Perceptions in Education
  • Student Feedback
  • AI-Generated Content (AIGC)

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Perceptions of Student Feedback: A comparative study of AI-generated and Human-generated content'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this