Women’s Experiences of Continuous Fetal Monitoring – A Mixed-Methods Systematic Review

Introduction: Antepartum stillbirth is often preceded by detectable signs of fetal compromise, including changes in fetal heart rate and movement. It is hypothesised that continuous fetal monitoring could detect these signs more accurately and objectively than current forms of fetal monitoring and allow for timely intervention. This systematic review aimed to explore available evidence on women’s experiences of continuous fetal monitoring to investigate its acceptability prior to clinical implementation and to inform clinical studies.

Material and methods: Systematic searching of four electronic databases (Embase, PsycINFO, MEDLINE and CINAHL), using key terms defined by initial scoping searches, identified a total of 35 studies. Following title and abstract screening by two independent researchers five studies met the inclusion criteria. Studies were not excluded based on language, methodology or quality assessment. An integrative methodology was used to synthesise qualitative and quantitative data together.

Results: Forms of continuous fetal monitoring used included Monica AN24 monitors (n=4) and phonocardiography (n=1). Four main themes were identified: practical limitations of the device, negative emotions, positive perceptions and device implementation. Continuous fetal monitoring was reported to have high levels of participant satisfaction and was preferred by women to intermittent cardiotocography.

Conclusion: This review suggests that continuous fetal monitoring is accepted
by women. However, it has also highlighted both the paucity and heterogeneity of current studies and suggests further research should be conducted into women’s experiences of continuous fetal monitoring before such devices can be used clinically.